Visual Wilderness
  • Get Started
  • Shop
    • SPECIAL OFFERS
    • STREAMING SERVICE
    • Browse by Topic
    • Learn To Shoot
    • Post Processing
    • Online Classes
    • eBooks
    • Landscape Photography Guide
  • Blog
    • Blog
    • Guest Photographers
  • About
  • My Account
    • My Account
  • Search
  • Menu Menu
  • 0Shopping Cart
Landscape Photography Article on Photography Filters by Jay Patel

Should I carry Graduated Neutral Density Filters?

July 6, 2020/in Equipment/by Jay Patel

Our landscape photography students are alway curious about Graduated Neutral Density Filters (GND Filters or Graduated ND Filters). They are designed to reduce the dynamic range of the landscape photo you are trying to capture and allow you capture an high dynamic range photo with a single shot.

So it is perfectly natural for us to get this question:

Should I carry Graduated Neutral Density Filters or just rely high dynamic range (HDR) processing in Photoshop?

Our answer is always the same… it depends“.  The important thing is to understand the advantages of each option and to know when to use one or the other… or both. If you know how to use a GND filters, you can produce the results with a graduated neutral density filters that are very similar to a manually-blended image.

About Graduated Neutral Density Filters

A GND filter is designed to reduce the amount of light coming through part of the lens. These filters are great for landscape photographers because they allow us to photograph sky and foreground with a single exposure, even if the range of light is pretty broad. A 2-stop GND will reduce the amount of light coming through half the lens by 2 full stops – so I can cover the sky in my photography composition with the dark part of the filter. The landscape in the foreground will remain unaffected.

Take a look at the landscape photos of Mt. Adam captured in Mount Adams Wilderness in Washington. In the first image, I used our manual Blending with Light Photoshop workflow to blend two bracketed images using Photoshop layers and masks. The goal when blending images is to preserve the natural shadows and all the detail in the highlights. In the end, we want to create an image that is as close as possible to our memory of the reality of the scene.

  • Photo 1: Example of Exposure Blending in Photoshop, Trout Lake, Mt. Adams Recreational Area, Washington by Jay Patel

    Photo 1: Example of Exposure Blending in Photoshop, Trout Lake, Mt. Adams Recreational Area, Washington

  • Photo 2: Captured using a Graduated Neutral Density Filter, Trout Lake, Mt. Adams Recreational Area, Washington by Jay Patel

    Photo 2: Captured using a Graduated Neutral Density Filter, Trout Lake, Mt. Adams Recreational Area, Washington

The second photos was taken in exactly the same spot – just a few minutes earlier. For this shot, Jay used a 3-stop GND filter. The filter successfully brought down the highlights in the sky so that the camera could capture the entire dynamic range in just one shot. You may notice that the trees at the base of the mountain are much darker in this image. That’s a result of the use of the GND filter.

In this case, the GND filter worked well to reduce the brightness at the top of the image, but it also darkened the trees more than we’d like. For this particular image, the manually-blended landscape photo is just a bit closer to the reality of the scene that evening. So does it mean that it is better than then one created using the GND photography filter? Not necessarily. For this particular image, the dead vegetation at the horizon was not appealing enough to call it a better image.

As you can see from the Mt. Adams example, we can easily replace a GND filter with a manually-blended landscape photo. So, why should one bother to purchase a GND filter? In the Mt. Adam’s photo above, it was not my intention to darken the vegetation in the mid-ground.

When to use Graduated Neutral Density Filter

However, there are times when I would intentionally choose to darken part of the landscape photo using a GND filter. This may be because the details in that part of the image do not make the image more appealing or I want to include a silhouette in my image.

Silhouette created using a Graduated Neutral Density Filter, Canon Beach, Oregon by Jay Patel

Silhouette effect in landscape photography created using a Graduated Neutral Density Filter, Canon Beach, Oregon

In the landscape photo from Oregon, I used a GND filter to satisfy both these criteria to come away with a stunning shot from Canon Beach. In this case, having a GND filter allowed me to get it right in-camera and simplified my post-processing workflow.

When NOT to use Graduated Neutral Density Filter

Take a look at this shot by Varina of the Toadstool hoodoo from Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument in Utah. The light was really nice – the sky was changing color a few minutes before sunrise, and very soft morning light kissed the orange rocks in front of me. The sun was getting ready to rise over her left shoulder – and the scene was pretty evenly lit, since Varina wasn’t shooting into the sun. The problem was that it was not possible to capture the entire dynamic range in a single frame without a Graduated Neutral Density filter… and Varina didn’t want to use one.

Landscape photo created with exposure bracketing & Photoshop Layers & Masks by Varina Patel

Landscape photo created with exposure bracketing & Photoshop Layers & Masks

Why not? Well, as you can see, the horizon in this shot is not straight. GND filters are perfect when the horizon is relatively straight. We use them for sunset or sunrise shots – where the sky is bright and the ground is dark. The filter can slide up or down to allow the photographer to adjust for the position of the horizon. They are incredibly useful little buggers if you enjoy landscape photography.

Unfortunately, in this photograph, the line between sky and ground isn’t straight. A GND filter would have made a dark line across the top of the hoodoo. No good. So Varina had to use exposure bracketing instead. She took two photographs from the same spot – using a remote release to make sure the camera didn’t move at all between exposures. The first shot was exposed correctly for the sky – so the sky looked great, but the ground was too dark. The second shot was exposed correctly for the ground – which meant the sky was too bright.

Varina then used Photoshop layers and masks to combine these two camera exposure and create a final landscape photo that represents the scene as I remember it.

There are times when we prefer to use a graduated neutral density filter over a manually blended landscape photo. Here is a short video where Jay explain why we carry a GND filter.

Cover for Graduated Neutral Density Filters Video by Jay Patel

More About Graduated Neutral Density Filters

In the end, it’s all about understanding the options that are available. Take the time to experiment with GND filters and HDR processing. Find out what works best in any given situation. Most importantly, make the effort to understand WHY that approach is best. Each option has it’s place. We teach our students how to use GND filters during our on-the-ground workshops… and we teach manual blending techniques in video courses.

About Author Jay Patel

I could startoff like this – “Seeds of Jay Patel’s appreciation for beautiful places were planted early in his childhood….” but it would get boring really fast. I will just sum it up and say that I am a Landscape and Wilderness Photographer who loves to capture dramatic light. My photographs have been published in various magazines, calendars and advertising materials throughout the world.
Patience is a virtue...unless you are chasing your dreams

Website | Google+ | Facebook | Twitter | Linkedin | Pinterest

Tags: Photography Filters
You might also like
Landscape Photography Article on ND Filters by Varina PatelGetting Creative with ND Filters
Landscape Photography Article on Photography Filters by Joshua SnowThe only Photography Filters you need to carry
The ND photography filters that Athena Carey in black and white photography blog postWhat ND Filters I Carry and Why
Landscape photography by Bruarfoss, Iceland Jay PatelHow to Use ND Filters for Long Exposure Photography
Landscape Photography Article on Photography Filters by Guest Author Jim Schubert3 Ways to use your GND and ND Photography Filters
Long Exposure Photography of Patagonian Sunset with Circular Polarizer and ND Filters by Chrissy DonadiOvercoming Challenges of ND Filters in Long Exposure Photography
8 replies
  1. Leanne Moore
    Leanne Moore says:
    May 7, 2019 at 6:03 pm

    I agree with using filters. I have changed cameras systems and gone micro 4 thirds now and don’t have a filter system for it yet. Been using HDR and blending in post and just not quite getting the results I want. I like the look of the filters you used in the video, can you tell me which brand they are please? Or what you would recommend.

    • Jay Patel
      Jay Patel says:
      May 7, 2019 at 9:46 pm

      Hello Leanne,

      We use Benro Filters System. Here is a starter kit that will get you 10% OFF: Visual Wilderness Starter Kit. You can then add other filters as needed to this kit.

  2. Matt
    Matt says:
    May 7, 2019 at 10:32 am

    I use filters as I prefer to not have to do a lot of work in post. I might miss out on a few things here and there but it is worth it to me in the end. The lake photo is interesting though. What type of GND was that? Was it a soft, medium, or hard GND? As you completely lost the middle of the frame, I am assuming that it was a hard, or possibly medium?

    • Jay Patel
      Jay Patel says:
      May 7, 2019 at 1:33 pm

      It was soft GND Filter, but with reflections the filter transition started just above the grass in the front and ended where the lake touches the horizon.

  3. Daryl (Butch) Butcher
    Daryl (Butch) Butcher says:
    August 23, 2011 at 5:24 pm

    Agree entirely and I particularly appreciate the “not overcooked” HDR treatment. I realize that “reality” is in the mind. But some “reality” reminds me of the supposed view of objects as seen by someone with a mental aberration … I see overcooked HDR as a type of lens aberration but in the lens of the mind. Wish I had the time and physical ability to get in the wilds like I once did but now with all of the advantages of digital rather than lugging a Hasselblad. Need I say that I like your work? Butch

    • Varina Patel
      Varina Patel says:
      August 23, 2011 at 5:41 pm

      Thanks Butch! :) I’m glad you like our work. We love what we do. ;)

      I do think that each of us has a different perception of reality… so the best I can do is create an image that is realistic in my own mind. :)

  4. Stephen Desroches
    Stephen Desroches says:
    May 17, 2011 at 6:29 am

    I agree, it’s a non debate and kind of like debating the best B&W conversion.

    • Varina Patel
      Varina Patel says:
      May 17, 2011 at 7:34 am

      :) Thanks Stephen. That’s exactly the point.

Comments are closed.

NATURE PHOTOGRAPHY NEWSLETTER

Join 45,000+ Nature Photographers and get the free eBooks, free creativity course & discount codes right in your inbox.

loader

Note: We never share your email address with anyone. More Info.

Blog | Shop | About

 Email Policy  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms

INFOCUS NEWSLETTER

Join 45,000+ other photographers and get the Free eBooks, Free Creativity Course & Discount Codes right in your inbox.


loader

Note: We never share your email address with anyone. More Info.

All Rights Reserved, © Copyright Visual Wilderness

Handheld Landscape Photography Tips to capture Stunning PhotosCover for handheld landscape photography blogs post by Charlotte GibbCover for Wildlife Photography blog post by Rahul SachdevCreative Wildlife Photography with Shutter Speed and Aperture
Scroll to top

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies.

OK

Cookie and Privacy Settings



How we use cookies

We may request cookies to be set on your device. We use cookies to let us know when you visit our websites, how you interact with us, to enrich your user experience, and to customize your relationship with our website.

Click on the different category headings to find out more. You can also change some of your preferences. Note that blocking some types of cookies may impact your experience on our websites and the services we are able to offer.

Essential Website Cookies

These cookies are strictly necessary to provide you with services available through our website and to use some of its features.

Because these cookies are strictly necessary to deliver the website, refusing them will have impact how our site functions. You always can block or delete cookies by changing your browser settings and force blocking all cookies on this website. But this will always prompt you to accept/refuse cookies when revisiting our site.

We fully respect if you want to refuse cookies but to avoid asking you again and again kindly allow us to store a cookie for that. You are free to opt out any time or opt in for other cookies to get a better experience. If you refuse cookies we will remove all set cookies in our domain.

We provide you with a list of stored cookies on your computer in our domain so you can check what we stored. Due to security reasons we are not able to show or modify cookies from other domains. You can check these in your browser security settings.

Other external services

We also use different external services like Google Webfonts, Google Maps, and external Video providers. Since these providers may collect personal data like your IP address we allow you to block them here. Please be aware that this might heavily reduce the functionality and appearance of our site. Changes will take effect once you reload the page.

Google Webfont Settings:

Google Map Settings:

Google reCaptcha Settings:

Vimeo and Youtube video embeds:

Privacy Policy

You can read about our cookies and privacy settings in detail on our Privacy Policy Page.

Privacy Policy
Learn More
NATURE PHOTOGRAPHY NEWSLETTERJoin 45,000+ Nature Photographers

Unlock Your Photography Potential! Get Free Webinars, Tips, eBooks, and More Delivered Straight to Your Inbox! 📸✨

We never share your email address with anyone. More Info.

Enter your email address